Tony Cozier

Brathwaite a Chanderpaul in the making

The youngster shares a similar mindset and temperament with the senior pro, and has a similar unwavering concentration at the crease

Tony Cozier
Tony Cozier
07-Sep-2014
Kraigg Brathwaite had a lot of opportunities to use the late cut, West Indies v Bangladesh, 1st Test, St Vincent, 1st day, September 5, 2014

There is no beauty about Kraigg Brathwaite's batting but he has made an impact at the top  •  WICB Media

Shivnarine Chanderpaul had to wait into the late afternoon on the opening day of the first Test against Bangladesh in St Vincent on Friday before he could start his first Test innings as a 40-year-old.
By the time he got in, Kraigg Brathwaite was already past his second Test hundred; 19 years, 144 Tests and 27 hundreds junior, the opening batsman's single-minded defiance, driven by unwavering concentration, mark him as an unmistakable Chanderpaul clone.
Like with Chanderpaul, there is no beauty about his batting. There are no booming drives, no lofted hits; his most attacking strokes are the cut, and the occasional off-drive. The purpose of his batting is steady accumulation of runs, carefully compiled. There were 45 singles and 10 twos against 13 fours in his maiden hundred - 129 against New Zealand in Port-of-Spain in June; the count on Friday was 43-15-8.
Television analysts remark as much about his strong bottom hand as they do about the left-handed Chanderpaul's quirky front-on stance; along with the opposite way they stand at the crease and their place in the batting order, it is a trait they do not share.
Friday's was the latest of Brathwaite's hundreds. He is reliably reported to have close to 50 at all levels - school, domestic and international Under-19s, regional first-class and A team internationals and now Tests.
While Chanderpaul's mindset was fashioned as a boy by countless hours of batting on a three-quarter pitch against his father, uncle and the accommodating folk of Unity Village, just outside the Guyana capital of Georgetown, Brathwaite came through one of the West Indies' strongest cricket schools, Combermere in Barbados, which had previously nurtured the early development of 13 West Indies Test players.
Brathwaite was the 14th. Chris Jordan, who captained Combermere before taking up a scholarship at Dulwich College in England, is the 15th - the difference is that his team is his adopted England, where he made his name in the county game. (Neither is quite as globally famous or as wealthy as their contemporary, the pop superstar Rihanna, who was just Robyn Fenty at Combermere.)
Among the school's earlier Test men were two West Indies captains, Denis Atkinson and the revered Sir Frank Worrell, the third of the W triumvirate, Sir Clyde Walcott (who later transferred to Harrison College) and two outstanding fast bowlers of the 1930s, Herman Griffith and Manny Martindale, and another of the 1960s, Sir Wesley Hall.
Aged 17 years, 122 days, Derek Sealy had to be given permission by Combermere's headmaster to skip classes so he could play the 1930 Test against England at Kensington Oval. It was his first of 11, and he remains the youngest of all West Indies Test players.
Chanderpaul, 19, and Brathwaite, 18, were also teenagers on their Test debuts. Both took time to settle. Chanderpaul's first hundred - 137 not out against India in Bridgetown in 1997 - came in his 19th match; Brathwaite's breakthrough against New Zealand was in his 11th.
In the era of T20 cricket, Brathwaite is something of an anachronism. Selectors don't consider his name when sifting through their short-format options. He is not bothered; Chanderpaul has been similarly pigeonholed. Brathwaite adheres to his idol's mantra.
Brathwaite faces his first examination by 90mph pace on faster, bouncier pitches than he has so far encountered in three Tests in South Africa in December and January
"If you play bad shots, you're going to get out," Chanderpaul reasoned in an interview with me a couple of years back. "If you hit the ball in the air, you're going to get out. If you can bat to 50, you can bat to 100. In T20 cricket, guys just give themselves room and fire. They don't care if they get out. This is why Test cricket will always be the ultimate; it tests you as to whether you are a man or a boy."
With 156 Tests, 11,414 runs, 29 hundreds and an average of 51.88 (prior to the ongoing Test), Chanderpaul has long since proved his cricketing manhood. Brathwaite has only just set out on the journey to verify his.
With the exception of two U-19 World Cup tournaments in New Zealand and Australia, he has accumulated all his runs on the similar pitches of the Caribbean, Bangladesh and India. One newspaper described Bangladesh's bowling on Friday as "lightweight"; with two young promising spinners on debut, "bantamweight" would have been a more valid description.
Brathwaite faces his first examination by 90mph pace on faster, bouncier pitches than he has so far encountered in three Tests in South Africa in December and January. England, with their high-class swingers, James Anderson and Stuart Broad, follow next April and May. It will all be a "learning curve", to use the popular expression.
There are enough instances through the game's history to inform him of how quickly fortunes can change in this most fickle of sports. He need not go any further than the experiences of Adrian Barath and Kieran Powell, with whom he has shared opening partnerships for West Indies.
At 19, Barath was the youngest West Indian to score a hundred on debut, 104 against Australia in Brisbane in 2009. He went into subsequent decline; the last of his 15 Tests was two years ago.
The left-handed Powell joined an elite group of West Indians when he scored hundreds in each innings against Bangladesh in Dhaka in 2012. Like Barath, his form deserted him in series in India and New Zealand late last year; he was dropped after failures in the first Test against New Zealand in Kingston in June.
Brathwaite took his place. Given his impressive background and unencumbered by the demands of the other two formats of the game, it would be a disappointment, indeed a surprise, if he too drifts into early oblivion rather than gradually following the giant footsteps of Chanderpaul.

Tony Cozier has written about and commentated on cricket in the Caribbean for 50 years